Arguments for and against affirmative action summarize. Use at least seven credible sources for your essay, including at least two sources from. Gerhard casper on affirmative action the drive for diversity the case for affirmative action the case against affirmative action the time that binds. The conclusion of the dba is that the degrees of belief, or credences, that an agent attaches to the members of a set \x\ of sentences, statements, or propositions, should satisfy the axioms of probability. Times have changed discrimination is less prevalent. The best new argument for affirmative action the atlantic. Johnson, who laid the groundwork for affirmative action, with martin luther king jr. University of texas at austin was being heard, in december, 2015. Affirmative action, practiced by top colleges today, clearly isnt even coming close to fixing the racial inequalities in our education system. Affirmative action itself violates the principle of equality. Affirmative action programs are assessed based on a variety of ethical systems ranging from deontological and utilitarian to justice theories, and the arguments against affirmative action are similarly evaluated. Their arguments against affirmative action are that affirmative action results in discrimination based upon race and skin color. These consequences dont mean that these programs arent worth it. The courts decision in the case has upheld affirmative action.
It assumes that an agents degrees of belief are associated with her betting quotients such that 1 for an agent with degree of belief q in m a bet on or against m. This is done by first assuming that people with subjective probabilities would be willing to take fair bets on the basis of these probabilities. White men are more likely to resent women and minorities if they are continually passed up for positions, despite being the better qualified candidate, simply because they are white and male. It is associated with probabilities implied by the odds not being coherent, namely are being skewed in economics, the term usually refers to a sequence of trades that would leave one party strictly worse off and another strictly better off. Affirmative action in public higher education has been hanging by a thread for a while.
There are at least three main attempts to justify such affirmative action programs. A refreshingly honest book about affirmative action. The dutch book argument see also the related money pump argument shows that beliefs about probabilities must be quantitative and satisfy standard probability axioms. There are positives and negatives for affirmative action. List of books and articles about affirmative action online. What was most lacking in the book, however, was any real coverage of the effects, positive and negative, of affirmative action and of the cynical polititization of affirmative action. What are the arguments for and against affirmative action. Becker beckers meaning behind this argument is that students or employees who are affecting by affirmative. Affirmative action policy does not permit discrimination against protected classes for a complete list of protected classes, i refer you to this wikipedia article. Arguments affirmative action and the burden of argument. Summarize the arguments for and against affirmative action. This paper examines four major arguments advanced by opponents of race and gender conscious affirmative action and rebuts them on the basis of moral considerations. For discrimination by randall kennedy the boston globe. Affirmative action the principle of affirmative action affirmative action hereforth referred to as aa is defined as a set of practices undertaken by employers, university admission offices, and government agencies to go beyond nondiscrimination, with the goal of actively improving the economic status of minorities and women with regard to employment, education and business ownership and.
First, affirmative action implies admitting students who. Essay on against affirmative action 584 words bartleby. In 2003, the us supreme court upheld the university of michigan law schools affirmative action program. Demonstrators hold signs outside the supreme court as fisher v. Nondiscrimination alone will achieve our social goals. Groups that are in refutation of affirmative action professor gary becker, who states affirmative action policies lowers standards of account ability need to push employees or student to perform better. Offering additional liberties to people based on race places them into a situation that they will have to rise to overcome. As someone who has both seen and participated in affirmative action programs, i see two unintended consequences of such programs.
The supporters of affirmative action see the movement as a way for underrepresented groups such as, minorities, women and economically. The future of affirmative action new paths to higher education diversity after fisher v. Equality, affirmative action and justice johan rabe. The case against affirmative action if, after 25 years, affirmative action has not succeeded in ending discrimination, perhaps it is time to try something else. Aug 03, 2017 arguments affirmative action and the burden of argument. Although the arguments over racial preferences in college admissions usually called affirmative action by proponents have been around for many years, this issue is once again on the front burner due to the supreme courts decision to take fisher v. Sep 29, 2011 argumentative essay on affirmative action argumentative essay on affirmative action the fact that white people are not admitted, due to extra points that black students received by affirmative action s rule, represents a reverse discrimination because white students also are entitled to equal treatment, based on meritocracy. An unexpected victory for affirmative action the new yorker. Should universities continue affirmative action policies. Arguments against affirmative action are nonsense mit news. The dutch book argument has often been presented as establishing that degrees of belief that violate the axioms are irrational because they can or do lead to bad consequences.
The argument that affirmative action do not lead to true diversity sounds weak. The lists of arguments for and against affirmative action may be interesting to readers new to the affirmation action debate, even though they do not really serve to further maguires argument. Chapter 7 affirmative action and the case of allan bakke. The nifty nine arguments against affirmative action in higher education the college dean famed for putting the duke university english department on the map exposes the flaws in the nine arguments commonly used against affirmative action. The best short definition of affirmative action is one that focuses on its aim. Arguments for and against affirmative action the difficulty of overcoming the effects of past discrimination is as nothing compared with the difficulty of eradicating from our society the source of those effects, which is the tendency fatal to a nation such as ours to classify and judge men and women on the basis of their country of origin or the color of their skin. The case against affirmative action college of william. Affirmative action is a program based on ending discrimination, but in realty, it has only made discrimination worse. Dec 09, 2015 affirmative action in public higher education has been hanging by a thread for a while. In for discrimination, harvard law school professor randall kennedy issues a detailed argument in favor of affirmative action and its application via racebased methods. One impact of affirmative action is visible in the line of supreme court cases 17.
Cite examples that show there has been affirmative action for. Some lessons to draw from a scholar of black lives matter, as trumps justice department goes after affirmative action. Arguments against affirmative action bibliography philpapers. I think the main argument against affirmative action is that it is racist to give preferential treatment to anyone based on their race, and jobsplaces at a college should be based solely on someones abilities and intellectual merits. Arguments for and against the concepts of affirmative action and employment at will utilizing case law examples, discuss the arguments for and against the concepts of affirmative action and employment at will. Summarize the consequentialist arguments for and against. Arguments for affirmative action bibliography philpapers. Mar 02, 2008 i cant write you a thesis bc im just terrible at it. Cite examples that show there has been affirmative action for whites over much of the last 300 years.
Argument against affirmative action policies essay 1145 words 5 pages. Against this background, we can discuss the moral justification for affirmative action programs in particular, those with an element of preferential treatment. The uncomfortable truth about affirmative action and asian. Proponents on both sides of the issue claim clearcut evidence for the rightness of their arguments, yet evidence is hazy at best. Concepts and cases prenticehall, chapter 7, and gertrude ezorsky, discrimination, encyclopedia of ethics new york. Supreme courts decision last year to require a higher level of scrutiny for racebased affirmative action was a step toward destabilizing raceconscious admission plans, and universities must find new ways for now additional ones, but eventually substitute ones.
Affirmative action and american values michael rosenfields overview of affirmative action, affirmative action and justice charles lawrence and mari matsudas book we wont go back. Equaljusticeasend justifies the means of affirmative action. Supreme courts decision last year to require a higher level of scrutiny for racebased affirmative action was a step toward destabilizing raceconscious admission plans, and universities must find new ways for now additional ones, but eventually substitute ones to ensure diversity. In gambling, a dutch book or lock is a set of odds and bets which guarantees a profit, regardless of the outcome of the gamble. Affirmative action is an outcome of the 1960s civil rights movement, intended to provide equal opportunities for members of minority groups and women in education and employment ncsl, 2014. This is since the emergence of affirmative action led to social awareness within the society and also led to institution of antidiscrimination laws which made race be of less concern compared to social class.
Arguments for and against affirmative action 749 words. A type of probability theory that postulates that profit opportunities will arise when inconsistent probabilities are assumed in a given context and are in violation of the. Dutch book arguments stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Arguments for and against affirmative action summarize the. This essay on arguments for and against affirmative. This page is based on parts of manuel velasquez, business ethics. Arguments for affirmative action in social and political philosophy. List of books and articles about affirmative action. Arguments for and against affirmative action essay example. This is part of the history, and its absence makes this only a 50 percent effort. Correctly implemented affirmative action is an economic necessity, because the country cannot afford the waste of human potential rabe 2001 against reverse discrimination creates resentment among whites. In three cases in 1989, the supreme court undercut courtapproved affirmative action plans by giving greater standing to claims of reverse discrimination, voiding the use of minority setasides where past discrimination against minority contractors was unproven, and restricting the use of statistics to prove discrimination, since statistics did. For his own part, professor putnam filed an amicus brief in the fisher case objecting to the use of his findings in arguments against affirmative action.
It is clear that the problem of past racialgender discrimination has not disappeared. Debating supreme court decisions mcpherson, stephanie sammartino on. The case against affirmative action stanford magazine. Oct 01, 2005 the bakke case and the affirmative action debate. Here at mit, a colleague and friend wrote an article questioning affirmative action which has sparked a lively debate.
Argumentative essay on affirmative action argumentative essay on affirmative action the fact that white people are not admitted, due to extra points that black students received by affirmative actions rule, represents a reverse discrimination because white students also are entitled to equal treatment, based on meritocracy. This new guide to the literature presents hundreds descriptions of books, reports and articles dealing with all aspects of affirmative action including. He summarizes the core of the arguments against an affirmative action policy. Affirmative action is one of the most controversial issues of our times. They say that affirmative action never result in true diversity. Men argue that it is absolutely unfair to judge candidates on the basis of gender. Jun 23, 2016 demonstrators hold signs outside the supreme court as fisher v. I cant write you a thesis bc im just terrible at it. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. I argue that the post1990 practice of giving leadership positions in companies to nonexcommunists is an example of affirmative action. Jul 31, 20 affirmative action, practiced by top colleges today, clearly isnt even coming close to fixing the racial inequalities in our education system. Affirmative action is legislation created to give opportunity to minorities, but is still a form of discrimination. It has caused segregated dorms and many minorities to be compromised. Arguments for and against the concepts of affirmative.
412 715 738 1306 904 193 603 1453 1298 1039 7 1060 27 641 511 178 791 95 1435 951 676 229 86 1468 834 264 219 17 1524 910 132 929 1215 971 976 1013 567 1100 1100 170 1122